The NHL has a problem. The league shows itself as a united front publicly; willing to clean up the game and provide the safety protocol for its players. Privately, however, factions of voices deem the work of newly appointed NHL Vice President of Player Safety and Hockey Operations as being outlandish and harsh. Is that not what he was brought in to do?
For years, players have grown accustomed to receiving the, seemingly standard, two game suspension for any on-ice altercation. Instead of serving as a time to reflect and understand their actions, it was more like an opportunity to recharge their internal batteries and maybe mend a few nagging injuries. So obviously that needed to be addressed. Well maybe used in conjunction with a hefty fine, a light suspension would be acceptable, you wonder? Not so fast. Consider the fact that, in the current flux of the collective bargaining agreement, the maximum fine that can be imposed on an offending player is $2,500. For an athlete making a few million dollars per season, that is the equivalent of reaching deep into your car seat, collecting the correct amount of coins, and paying a toll.
To differentiate from the dark cloud that loomed over his predecessor, Colin Campbell, Brendan Shanahan felt that in order to change the culture of the NHL, the traditional penalties were just not working. Thus, his approach has been simple yet effective in relaying his mission to the NHL and its fans. Incidents would be reviewed publicly and suspensions would be explained. While people may snicker at his stance as being on the cutting edge; in the world of sports, it has proven to be forward thinking. Instead of sitting behind his desk and imposing his will, Shanahan appears front and center, explaining why a particular action violates the league’s policies and takes into consideration any past transgressions of the offending player in doling out punishment.
With the NHL just two weeks into the season, Brendan Shanahan’s quest is being challenged by some general managers and agents who deem his rulings to be unjust and too harsh. Remember, these were the same people who were crying for a regime change in disciplinary power. As players are being policed with an iron fist, there have been a growing number of executives who have altered their stance in a blink of an eye.
It is important to read between the lines on this matter. Do not be suckered by the smoke and mirror tactics that this group is evoking. Suspending players for a prolonged period of time can hinder the chances of his team from accumulating points in the standings. For franchises, failure to make the playoffs translates to lost revenue. For agents, if a player does not receive compensation during a leave of absence, they do not collect their share of the pie. Funny how those facts are left out of their words when reporters are present and the cameras are rolling.
Watch a telecast in the United States or Canada and you will come across naysayers, such as Don Cherry and Mike Milbury, who clamor for the era in which they cannot themselves seem to move past. As the league has improved its skill level, grown in the average size of players, and undergone an equipment revolution, people such as the aforementioned bumbling idiots have remained steadfast in their stubbornness and machoism. Face it Milbury, the game is not the same as when you played. For better or for worse, it has evolved. Sure, there are elements that fans may yearn to return to the game that were evident during your place in time. However, the same argument can be made about the current state of hockey. Does anyone really miss the two line pass? So move on, get over it and quit your crying.
Brendan Shanahan has the unfavorable job of always being the bad guy in every situation. Quite simply, he will not appease everyone. His new approach to an old problem may or may not work, but there is only one way to know for sure. Hockey is a game of reaction, where the play is often too fast to process the action and develop thoughts. Instinct must take over for a player to succeed. By imposing severe suspensions for unwarranted acts, Shanahan may be able to alter the wiring of a player’s mind and prevent potential occurrences from happening. So back off and let him do the job no one else wants to do.